Friday, December 28, 2012

Musings: Snuff

Before I can even get into this book, I must say one thing - is that supposed to be Sam Vimes on the cover?!  Because he looks nothing like I have pictured him.  I always imagine him to be quite scruffy, well on his way to having a potbelly.  And being much older than he appears here.  I'm just going to assume it's one of the other characters on the cover here.

Anyway!  Snuff!  When I reviewed Dodger, I said I liked the book but I was disappointed that it wasn't about a young Sam Vimes in Discworld.  And then I read Snuff and I admit that I am disappointed that this book isn't about a young Sam Vimes in Discworld, too.

Instead, it's about Sam Vimes as Commander of the City Watch, Duke of Ankh, devoted husband and doting father.  He takes a family vacation to the country and, of course, stumbles upon some trouble.  A goblin girl has been murdered, and when Vimes starts investigating, he comes upon the appalling realization that people believe goblins are vermin and they treat them (or mistreat them) as such.  Thus, Vimes, with the help of his glorious wife Sybil and his very capable valet Wilikins, set out to make all right with the world again.

I love Discworld, but I've missed the City Watch a lot in the past several outings.  I was excited to get back to the characters I love in this book.  But, and I can't quite believe I'm saying this, I almost wish this book wasn't centered on Commander Vimes.

The thing is, Sam Vimes' story is no longer the most interesting one in Ankh-Morpork, or even in the City Watch. There are so many fantastic, fascinating characters in the City Watch with such untapped potential that Viimes could still make Death-like cameos and save the day without needing to be the centerpoint of the story, because there's not that much more of his story to tell.  I wish we got more of Carrot and Angua and Cheery instead, as they must be chock-full of stories.

But at least with Vimes, we get Sybil, and she is really awesome.  I have said it in pretty much every Pratchett book I've ever reviewed, but Pratchett is such a feminist and writes such satisfyingly intelligent women, that I want to give a copy of his Tiffany Aching series to every single epic fantasy writer out there.

This book, though, is not about Sybil.  It's about oppression and institutional racism and the horrible, numbing effects it can have on both the perpetrators and the victims.  There are some truly ugly things that happen in this novel, and Pratchett doesn't shy away from sharing the details or the consequences of those actions.  But as always, these are balanced by humor and trust and friendship.

I don't think Snuff is the strongest book in the City Watch series - so many of the books in this series confront racism in some form that it's hard to keep the stories fresh and different - but that doesn't mean it isn't worth reading.  It confronts a lot of hard topics that are ripe for discussion and that should be acknowledged.  But I think many of those topics were dealt with better in previous books centered on the Watch, and I would recommend those before this one, particularly as this one draws so heavily from the happenings in Thud!, a book that I wish I remembered better than I do.

Note:  I listened to this book on audio.  I am not sure if that was a good decision.  On the one hand, the narrator was brilliant - he did so many different voices and accents that I really got a sense of the huge diversity of characters.  On the other hand - he did so many different voices and accents that I got very absorbed in trying to figure out if that accent matched up with the accent I expected for that particular character and they didn't always match up.  So... you decide what's best for you!

Note 2:  There is no Death cameo in this book, and there was just such a PERFECT scene for him to come, I was so sad not to see him arrive in ALL CAPITAL LETTERS.


  1. I listened to this one in audio as well, but it was my first experience with Terry Pratchett's work so it was a little bit of a struggle for me. However, I do want to dive into the Discworld series from book 1 and then later, when I feel a bit more "expert" on Pratchett's world, might dive back into audio at that point! I'm glad you enjoyed it!

  2. The City Watch is my favourite story arc in the Discworld series (The Fifth Elephant is my favourite book) and I really enjoyed this one too. I do agree that Pratchett deals with some very dark material here but he does it with sensitivity and humour. And I love Lady Sybil, she is indeed glorious!

  3. No Death? But he is so good :/
    Still sounds good

  4. Why do there have to be so many in this series? (wail) I haven't even started it yet. Not sure whether to do audio or print...

  5. That cover is a Paul Kidby illustration, I think - he has done the UK covers. This is the first time that the US edition has his work, as far as I know. I'm familiar with that Sam Vimes from The Art of Discworld, which Kidby did with Terry Pratchett - a great book!

    I've had this one on my TBR stacks since it came out. I really need to read it - so I just skimmed your post.

  6. Well, I wonder if Pratchett's daughter will return to some of the other characters in the City Watch miniseries (also my favorite). With Pratchett having Alzheimer's, I wonder if all of the intricacies of the characters is just too difficult. When I heard that he had it, it broke my heart. I love the Discworld series.

  7. I seriously need to find time to read this series!

  8. We should reread Thud! together one of these days. I remember being really impressive with how Pratchett addressed racism in it when I first read it, but like you I wish I remembered the details better.

  9. At the moment Sam Vimes, this older Sam Vimes...husband and MY favorite character in Discworld. That is solely because the only book I've read in Discworld is Thud! and I've read part of Snuff. Enjoyed Thud! tremendously and I have no doubt I'll continue to like Snuff when I get back to it.

    I gather one of the cool things about Discworld is that everyone connects with different characters. It is that husband/father aspect that attracts me so much to Sam, that and the fact that he is the head of a mixed bag of employees and I feel very connected to that too, lol!

  10. No Death? That's always one of my favourite parts of a Discworld series.

    It's been a while since I read a Discworld book. I was just thinking yesterday that I need to read on soon.


I read every comment posted on this blog, even if it sometimes takes me a while to respond. Thank you for taking the time and effort to comment here! Unless you are spamming me, in which case, thanks for nothing.