Friday, October 9, 2009

Review: Wolf Hall

Title: Wolf Hall

Author: Hilary Mantel

Publisher: Henry Holt & Co.

# of Pages: 532

I received this book for free to review.

Favorite Line:
Why does everything you know, and everything you've learned, confirm you in what you believed before? Whereas in my case, what I grew up with, and what I thought I believed, is chipped away a little and a little, a fragment then a piece and then a piece more. With every month that passes, the corners are knocked off the certainties of this world.

Plot Summary:
Hilary Mantel's sweeping novel begins with Thomas Cromwell as a pre-teen on the ground, being beaten by his drunkard father. He thinks he will die, but instead, he gets up, dusts himself off, and lives to see another day. This
describes Cromwell throughout the novel- tenacious and tough. Wolf Hall is yet another book in a long line about the Tudors, but Mantel's focus on Thomas Cromwell- first through his relationship with his father, and then with Cardinal Wolsey, and then with King Henry VIII and Anne Boleyn- gives us a very different view of the proceedings. Here is an author who does not focus on Henry's lust for Anne, and that as the starting point for setting off a continent-wide debate on religion. She focuses instead on Cromwell, and his true hope that Anne's marriage to Henry will set England on a new course of freedom and equality.

I don't think my summary above does any justice to this novel. Its scope and breadth is immense. Hilary Mantel sets out to describe a tumultuous period in English history, not by focusing on the main event- Henry and Anne- but by showing the struggle faced by those more behind the scenes. Thomas Cromwell says, late in the book, that worlds are not changed by kings and popes, but by two men sitting at a table, coming to an agreement, or by the exchange of thoughts and ideas across countries. And that is what Mantel seems to believe, too; thus, she does not focus her story on the huge proclamations or big meetings. She shows us Cromwell, alone at his desk, thinking and reminiscing. She details short, almost off-hand conversations between Cromwell and his wonderful family. And then, sometimes, she will give us fascinating debates between Cromwell and Sir Thomas More, the "man for all seasons" who was ruthless in his practices to rid England of heretics.

Even the title of the book is more suggestive than straight-forward. Wolf Hall is the seat of the Seymour clan, but no scene in the book takes place there. The Seymours make cameos, and Cromwell takes note of them, but Wolf Hall is a distant building for most of the book. Instead, it represents Cromwell's forward thinking. He is grateful to the Boleyns for his rise in court and favor, but he does not allow himself to depend on them. He tells his son, "'s all very well planning what you will do in six months, what you will do in a year, but it's no good at all if you don't have a plan for tomorrow." And Cromwell always, always has a plan for tomorrow.

I am not sure if I fully believe in Mantel's reconstruction of Cromwell as a man who wanted only to reform England, and was so forward-thinking in his ideals. However, it's understandable; Cromwell was a blacksmith's son who rose to prominence at a time when everyone important was noble or royal. Of course he would want the same opportunities for his family and friends. Perhaps in the promised sequel, we'll get the hardened and more ruthless Cromwell that people remember.

Mantel's writing style drew me in completely. This book reminded me a great deal of A Place of Greater Safety, in terms of writing style. I don't think I enjoyed it as much as that book, but that's probably because the French Revolution absorbs me far more than Tudor England does. Mantel writes so lyrically, so adeptly. She immerses herself in the period- the food, the clothes, the heat, the stench. She researched this book for years, and it's obvious in the product. But she does not get bogged down by her facts, or by history. Her flair for witty conversation brings her characters to life, giving them flesh and blood where history only gives them stark facts and wooden portraits. Yes, Cardinal Wolsey was able to tell a joke. Yes, Cromwell loved his wife. We don't see those things, 500 years later.

The only parts of the writing that annoyed me, stylistically, were as follows: Mantel usually uses quotation marks to denote conversation, but sometimes she does not; Mantel uses the pronoun "he" too much. The first is just frustrating in reading such a thick novel because it can interrupt a rhythm. The second is confusing because there are often multiples "he" in conversation, and you can't be sure who she is referring to, all the time.

Other than that, though- this book is great! Very worthy of the Booker Prize, in my view, and I look forward to the sequel. Lovers of epic, varied novels will be thrilled. Not only are extensive family trees provided, but there is also a five-page long list of characters. This isn't the sort of book you read for ten minutes on the morning commute. It's one to savor with a cup of wine.

And here's an excellent review from the New Yorker.


  1. Great review! I'm almost half way through the book and the present tense and maddening use of "he" (as you mentioned) is driving me nuts! Her style if definately different and I haven't decided for sure what I think of it.

  2. I am looking forward to reading this when it comes in for me at the library!

  3. Excellent review, I think of Cromwell as sort of a hardass, so hopefully he is one in the sequel, wouldn't want my perceptions distorted. :-)

    I think I may have to actively seek out this Booker Prize winner :-)

  4. A worthy winner, I do feel like reading it now. I think it would suit me well

  5. Great review! I've already decided to add it to my Tudor shelves, it sounds well written and I do love an alternatate view than Henry or one of his wives.

  6. Excellent review! I didn't think it was possible for me to be more excited about reading this book, but after reading your review I am! I particularity like the fact that she gets all the small details of the period in the story. I really enjoy books that immerse me in the small things. I also like that this is a story told from a different perspective than the usual. I will have to let you know what I think after I read it.

  7. I cannot WAIT to read this book, and your review has only made me want to read it more.

  8. Wonderful review - I waited to read it until after I finished it. You summed it up so well!


I read every comment posted on this blog, even if it sometimes takes me a while to respond. Thank you for taking the time and effort to comment here! Unless you are spamming me, in which case, thanks for nothing.