Tuesday, April 19, 2011

Musings: Lost and Found

The Lost Thing
I fell in love with Shaun Tan after reading The Arrival last year.  Tan's artistic style- grounded in reality but with a strong dose of "otherworldliness"- was a perfect way to relate the highs and lows of immigrating to a new country.  Tan recently won an Oscar for the movie The Lost Thing, based on the story he authored and illustrated.  Lost & Found includes The Lost Thing in the collection, as well as The Red Tree and Rabbits.

The title fits perfectly.  All three stories center on the idea of loss- loss of hope, loss of wonder, and loss of culture.  What Tan does so well in all his stories is to point out how blind society has become.  How we are too busy to care about others or see the wonders that exist in the world around us.  How good things are around if we just take the time to see them and allow them to brighten our days.  I loved all three stories, though my favorite was The Lost Thing.  What follows are short reviewitas of all three stories.
The Red Tree 
The Red Tree follows a girl through one day as she feels sad and out-of-sorts with the world.  Some reviewers have said the story is about a girl struggling through depression, but I disagree.  I think it's more universal.  I've never struggled with depression, but I have had those days when it seems like everything is going wrong, and no one understands, and nothing will ever get better.  I think everyone has those, and Tan uses brilliant graphics to describe this feeling of dejection.  A girl in a massive building, with faceless people all around her, but no one stopping to ask if she's all right.  A big, depressed fish moving through the city, unseen by anyone.   The imagery in this story is beautiful and universal.  Here's a link to a video version of The Red Tree.

The Lost Thing
The Lost Thing is about a boy who finds an unusual friend (that looks kind of like a cross between a teapot and an octopus) and cares for it, while everyone else ignores it or tries to pass it on to someone else.  It is one of the more political and satirical of the stories I've read by Tan, with many pointless government notices around the borders and random slogans like, "Today is the tomorrow you were promised yesterday."  The boy takes time out of his day to become friends with the outsider thing, that is lost and doesn't know where it belongs.  And he helps it to find a new home.  "I mean, I can't say that the thing actually belonged in the place where it ended up. In fact, none of the things there really belonged. They all seemed happy enough though, so maybe that didn't matter."  The story is a great one for anyone who has (and who hasn't?) ever felt on the outside looking in, the circle trying to fit the square.  It's also about the kindness and curiosity that is innate to children but seems to disappear as we get older.  I loved it, and I am crossing my fingers that the movie is available for me to watch some time soon!  Here's the movie trailer.

Rabbits
The last story in the collection is Rabbits.  This story was written by John Marsden and illustrated by Tan and it's the story of a native people being overwhelmed by invading colonists.  A story that's been told many times, true, but also one that needs repetition.  Once again, the illustrations are excellent and, to me, give the story a much deeper and stronger meaning than the words alone.  I loved the narration by native species of Australia (echidnas, I think?) and the rabbits as foreigners.  Very fitting especially as Europeans brought rabbits to Australia and the rabbits multiplied like crazy and wrought havoc on the native ecosystem.  It was not a preachy portrayal at all- it was more like a sigh of inevitability, which is sad in itself.

I really enjoyed all three stories in this collection and look forward to spending many hours closely examining the artwork.  I am sure there are a lot of hidden symbols and gifts in the panels to find, and I look forward to doing so!  I don't think these stories are aimed at children, though.  More high school and up, I'd say.

Note:  This review is based on an advanced reader's copy.  I received this book for free to review.

19 comments:

  1. Scott Tan is just an AMAZING author and illustrator. I keep looking out for this book.

    ReplyDelete
  2. GRR, I meant Shaun Tan! Wake up brain.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I need to experience more of his books... I never think of him when I am requesting books from the library.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Vivienne - I got what you meant :-) I agree, he's so inventive!

    Kelly - Using the word "Experience" is quite right. It's a very active and engaged reading.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I have been hearing such amazing things about this book, and have loved looking at all the illustrations. I really think that Tan has a gift in his ability to create these stories where there are no words, but only pictures to tell complex and moving tales. I so want to read this book, and after reading your review on this one, I want to go out and buy it now!

    ReplyDelete
  6. You know, I really loved The Red Tree, but I just read The Lost Thing over readathon and didn't like it at all! I mean, the story was fine, but the way the people were drawn (like Far-Side characters, as Jenners pointed out) really turned me off the art and the story both. The people didn't seem to fit with the rest of Tan's style. I don't know. It ended up being my least favorite Tan and the only one I've disliked. I turned it over to my kids, who like Tan a lot, and without telling them my thoughts, they all said the same thing. I guess we all must be very sensitive to the same triggers.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I adore Tan so I'm glad this one worked so well for you. I positively stood up and screeched when he won the Oscar. So far I love The Arrival and Tales from Outer Suburbia equally. Excited to try this one.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Zibilee - I think this is one of those books you can purchase and enjoy at various stages of your life, in a lot of different moods, and get something different out of it each time. I can see someone looking at it through various life stages and enjoying it each time.

    Amanda - Oh, interesting! Yes, I think it's a little different from his other artwork, but I personally thought it was a similar "feel" to The Arrival, especially with the loneliness and isolation that was present. I would want to read it again to figure out what all the government notices were for, though- it seemed a bit 1984 in that way and I wonder why.

    Andi - I've not read Tales from Outer Suburbia, but I want to very badly! I was also VERY excited for him winning the Oscar- hope I can watch that movie soon!

    ReplyDelete
  9. I always did like weird pics like that. If the book is for me then..not really, but I like the review :)

    ReplyDelete
  10. I always mean to get a Shaun Tan, but I never remember to when I go to request books from the library. I must remember! I must!

    ReplyDelete
  11. Oh how good that you got this for review! Shaun Tan is such a fantastic artist. His stuff reminds me of a slightly lighter-hearted Dave McKean -- there's something of the same surreal aesthetic that I absolutely love.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I loved this book! I think Rabbits was my favorite story followed by The Red Tree. Great review!

    ReplyDelete
  13. Blodeuedd- Aw, well it's not for everyone, I guess!

    She - I know what you mean, it's so hard to try to remember EVERYONE you want to read!

    Jenny - I am not familiar with Dave McKean, but I completely agree on digging the surrealist vibe.

    Vasilly - I liked them all :-)

    ReplyDelete
  14. I love Tan. I got interested in his work from reading Rabbits, which was a joint project with John Marsden. Then I started reading Tan's solo work. Love.

    ReplyDelete
  15. These stories sound fascinating. I'm sorry to say that I've not read anything by Tan, yet.

    ReplyDelete
  16. I love his artwork and really need to track down a copy of this book.

    ReplyDelete
  17. The illustrations are incredible!

    ReplyDelete
  18. I so want to read this one! My library doesn't have it so I'm waiting to get this one somehow. I loved The Arrivals too! Great review, btw! I loved how you evoked the sensations felt in each story!

    ReplyDelete
  19. They showed the movie of The Lost Thing here a couple of weeks ago and it was as good as you would expect an Oscar winning short film to be!

    ReplyDelete

I read every comment posted on this blog, even if it sometimes takes me a while to respond. Thank you for taking the time and effort to comment here! Unless you are spamming me, in which case, thanks for nothing.